Scams & Magic – Other Stage Magic Techniques Used in Scams
Part 8
Understanding the Methods Used by Both Scammers and Magicians to Deceive
Psychology of Scams – A SCARS Insight
Author:
• Tim McGuinness, Ph.D. – Anthropologist, Scientist, Director of the Society of Citizens Against Relationship Scams Inc.
Article Abstract
Stage magic techniques are notably similar to those used in relationship scams, with both relying on manipulating perception, distracting attention, and crafting controlled narratives.
In magic, techniques like “The Setup and Anticipation” build suspense and focus the audience’s expectations, while in scams, this creates emotional investment in victims. “Patter and Rapport” in magic engage and guide the audience, and in scams, build trust through personal stories. “Sleight of Hand” in magic hides the trick’s mechanics, whereas in scams, it involves subtle changes in narrative to extract more money.
Both use “Misdirection Through Details” to overwhelm and distract, “The Switch” to alter scenarios and evoke sympathy, “The Controlled Reveal” to maintain engagement and credibility, and “The Clean-Up” to conceal evidence or cover tracks. Recognizing these parallels can help individuals understand and guard against deceptive practices.
Other Stage Magic Techniques Used in Scams
From a stage magician’s perspective, several other techniques and elements of the stage magic process are also applicable to relationship scams. These techniques are designed to manipulate perception, distract attention, and create a controlled narrative, which are equally effective in both magic and scams.
The Setup and Anticipation
In Magic: The setup involves the magician establishing the premise of the trick, creating anticipation and expectations in the audience. This can involve storytelling, introducing props, or setting the stage for what is about to happen. The anticipation builds suspense and primes the audience to expect a certain outcome, which makes the eventual reveal or twist more impactful.
In Scams: Scammers use a similar approach by building a narrative that leads the victim to anticipate a particular outcome. For example, in a romance scam, the scammer might create an elaborate story about a future together, including plans to meet in person or marry. This setup creates emotional investment and anticipation in the victim, who becomes more willing to comply with the scammer’s requests, such as sending money for travel or other expenses.
Patter and Rapport
In Magic: Patter refers to the magician’s dialogue, which serves multiple purposes: engaging the audience, explaining the trick, and guiding their attention. Building rapport with the audience is crucial, as it helps establish trust and makes the audience more receptive to the magician’s cues and instructions.
In Scams: Scammers also use patter and rapport to build trust and a connection with the victim. They often engage in extensive conversations, sharing personal stories, and expressing empathy to create a bond. This rapport-building helps lower the victim’s defenses and makes them more susceptible to manipulation. For example, a scammer might share a detailed and emotional story about their background, which resonates with the victim and fosters a sense of intimacy and trust.
Sleight of Hand
In Magic: Sleight of hand involves the magician using dexterity and subtle movements to manipulate objects without the audience noticing. This technique is crucial for many classic magic tricks, such as card tricks or coin tricks, where the magician’s skillful hand movements deceive the audience into seeing something that isn’t there.
In Scams: While not physical, scammers use a metaphorical “sleight of hand” by carefully crafting their words and actions to mislead the victim. This might include changing details in their story to fit the victim’s responses or subtly shifting the narrative to extract more money. For instance, in a financial scam, the scammer might initially ask for a small amount of money, but as trust builds, they gradually increase their requests, always justifying them with plausible excuses.
The Misdirection Through Details
In Magic: Magicians often overload the audience with details or perform intricate hand movements that seem important but are actually irrelevant to the trick’s outcome. This misdirection through details keeps the audience’s attention occupied, preventing them from noticing the actual method behind the trick.
In Scams: Scammers use a similar technique by providing an overwhelming amount of information or irrelevant details. This can confuse the victim or make them feel that the scammer’s story is too complex to be false. For example, in a business scam, the scammer might present elaborate business plans, detailed financial forecasts, and complicated jargon to appear legitimate and distract the victim from noticing inconsistencies.
The Switch
In Magic: The switch involves replacing one object with another, often without the audience’s knowledge. This can be done through sleight of hand or using props like trapdoors or secret compartments. The switch is often the key to making the impossible seem possible.
In Scams: In relationship scams, the “switch” can occur when the scammer suddenly changes their persona or story. For instance, a scammer might initially present themselves as a successful professional but later reveal a tragic circumstance that requires financial assistance. This sudden switch in narrative is designed to evoke sympathy and urgency, making the victim more likely to send money or personal information.
The Controlled Reveal
In Magic: The controlled reveal is a technique where the magician reveals parts of the trick gradually, guiding the audience’s perception and emotions. This controlled pacing helps maintain suspense and ensures that the final reveal has maximum impact.
In Scams: Scammers use a similar approach by revealing information about themselves or the situation in a controlled manner. This might include sharing personal photos, fabricated documents, or staged conversations to build credibility. By controlling the flow of information, scammers keep the victim engaged and emotionally invested, making it harder for them to see the scam for what it is.
The Clean-Up
In Magic: The clean-up refers to the magician’s actions after the trick is performed, ensuring that any evidence of the method used is removed or concealed. This is crucial for maintaining the illusion and preventing the audience from figuring out how the trick was done.
In Scams: In scams, the clean-up involves the scammer covering their tracks, especially if they sense the victim is becoming suspicious. This can include deleting online profiles, creating excuses for why they can’t be contacted, or shifting to a new storyline that explains any inconsistencies. This clean-up phase is essential to avoid detection and prevent the victim from realizing the deception before it’s too late.
Understanding these techniques highlights the sophisticated psychological manipulation involved in both magic and scams. Both magicians and scammers rely on controlling perception, building trust, and managing attention to create convincing illusions. Recognizing these parallels can help individuals better understand and guard against deceptive practices, whether they’re watching a magic show or navigating interactions in their personal lives.
Continue the SCARS Institute Series on Scams & Magic
- Scams & Magic Part 1 – Understanding Financial Fraud Through The Lense Of Stage Magic Manipulation
- Scams & Magic Part 2 – How Relationship Scammers Use Techniques Similar To Magic Acts
- Scams & Magic Part 3 – The Prestige: The Ultimate Revelation
- Scams & Magic Part 4 – The Misdirection: A Key Element
- Scams & Magic Part 5 – The Backstory Setup: Crafting Believable Narratives
- Scams & Magic Part 6 – The Flourish: Adding Flair And Distraction
- Scams & Magic Part 7 – The Time Pressure: Urgency As A Tool
- Scams & Magic Part 8 – Other Stage Magic Techniques Used In Scams
- Scams & Magic Part 9 – The Setup And Anticipation
- Scams & Magic Part 10 – Patter And Rapport
- Scams & Magic Part 11 – Sleight Of Hand
- Scams & Magic Part 12 – The Misdirection Through Details
- Scams & Magic Part 13 – The Switch: Deception
- Scams & Magic Part 14 – The Controlled Reveal: Crafting Suspense
- Scams & Magic Part 15 – The Clean-Up: Final Acts
- Scams & Magic Part 16 – The Setup Or Pre-Show Work
- Scams & Magic Part 17 – The Build-Up: Crafting Suspense And Anticipation
- Scams & Magic Part 18 – The Turn: A Critical Moment
- Scams & Magic Part 19 – Forcing: Manipulating Choices
- Scams & Magic Part 20 – The Load: Strategic Placement
- Scams & Magic Part 21 – The Vanish: Disappearance Acts
- Scams & Magic Part 22 – Transformation: Shaping Realities
- Scams & Magic Part 23 – Restoration: Rebuilding
- Scams & Magic Part 24 – Stage Magic Glossary
More About Magic and Scams
- Equivocation – The Magician’s Choice – The Arts Of Manipulation
- Psychic Scams – Exploiting Scam Victims’ Cognitive Biases And Magical Thinking
- The Art Of Deception: The Fundamental Principals Of Successful Deceptions
- Paradoxical Persuasion – A Scammer Psychological Manipulation Technique
- Suggestibility – A Victim Vulnerability
More About The Psychology of Magic
- The Psychology Of Illusion: How Magicians Manipulate Your Mind And Perception | Alan Hudson
- Advanced Card Magic Techniques: The Ultimate Guide – Card Tricks
- 100 BEST Magic Tricks Revealed! (Video Tutorials) – Improve Magic
- The Magical Art of Manipulation
- Editorial: The Psychology of Magic and the Magic of Psychology – PMC (nih.gov)
- Psychology, stage magic, and demand characteristics — A.P. Grayson (apgrayson.com)
Please Leave Us Your Comment
Also, tell us of any topics we might have missed.
Thank you for your comment. You may receive an email to follow up. We never share your data with marketers.
Recent Reader Comments
- on Why People Blame Victims?: “After my 2nd reading of the article I am still impressed with how SCARS really understands the scam experience.” Oct 6, 20:18
- on Helping Friends & Family Better Understand Romance Scams: “This article is a great read for those who want to help a scam victim become a survivor.” Oct 6, 09:40
- on New Scam Victims – Support & Information Resources 2024: “So sorry to inform you I just had a guy pose as you he is on X please see if…” Oct 5, 22:39
- on Resilience Coping Recovery And Romance Scam Victims [UPDATED 2024]: “Thank you – we updated the whole article.” Oct 5, 01:11
- on How To Detect Scams In Someone You Know – A Guide For Family & Friends: “This article speaks the truth. It describes what the scam victim is going through perfectly.” Oct 4, 10:10
- on Resilience Coping Recovery And Romance Scam Victims [UPDATED 2024]: “I would like to be a SCARS Institute volunteer as a proof reader for the website as I love to…” Oct 3, 19:11
- on Scam Victim’s Responsibilities: “I have been blessed by so many people who didn’t know me yet helped me throughout my life. From someone…” Oct 3, 18:39
- on Forgiveness and Scams – Why It Matters So Much!: “Forgiveness is an obstacle along the road to recovery that is so easy to get stuck. So many emotions I…” Oct 3, 15:44
- on Scam Victim Relapse: “I am a survivor of a pig butcher scam, followed by a romance scam where a great deal of money…” Oct 3, 10:58
- on What To Do When Someone Close To You Experiences The Personal Trauma Of A Romance Scam: “As a scam victim myself, I appreciate this article and hope it finds its way to all of those who…” Oct 3, 10:06
Important Information for New Scam Victims
- Please visit www.ScamVictimsSupport.org – a SCARS Website for New Scam Victims & Sextortion Victims
- Enroll in FREE SCARS Scam Survivor’s School now at www.SCARSeducation.org
- Please visit www.ScamPsychology.org – to more fully understand the psychological concepts involved in scams and scam victim recovery
If you are looking for local trauma counselors please visit counseling.AgainstScams.org or join SCARS for our counseling/therapy benefit: membership.AgainstScams.org
If you need to speak with someone now, you can dial 988 or find phone numbers for crisis hotlines all around the world here: www.opencounseling.com/suicide-hotlines
SCARS Resources:
- Getting Started Right: ScamVictimsSupport.org
- Sextortion Scam Victims: Sextortion Victims Support – The Essentials (scamvictimssupport.org)
- For New Victims of Relationship Scams newvictim.AgainstScams.org
- Subscribe to SCARS Newsletter newsletter.againstscams.org
- Sign up for SCARS professional support & recovery groups, visit support.AgainstScams.org
- Join our Scam Survivors United Chat & Discussion Group facebook.com/groups/scam.survivors.united
- Find competent trauma counselors or therapists, visit counseling.AgainstScams.org
- Become a SCARS Member and get free counseling benefits, visit membership.AgainstScams.org
- Report each and every crime, learn how to at reporting.AgainstScams.org
- Learn more about Scams & Scammers at RomanceScamsNOW.com and ScamsNOW.com
- Scammer photos ScammerPhotos.com
- SCARS Videos youtube.AgainstScams.org
- Self-Help Books for Scam Victims are at shop.AgainstScams.org
- Donate to SCARS and help us help others at donate.AgainstScams.org
- Worldwide Crisis Hotlines: https://blog.opencounseling.com/suicide-hotlines/
Other Cyber Resources
- Block Scam Domains: Quad9.net
- Global Cyber Alliance ACT Cybersecurity Tool Website: Actionable Cybersecurity Tools (ACT) (globalcyberalliance.org) https://act.globalcyberalliance.org/index.php/Actionable_Cybersecurity_Tools_(ACT)_-_Simplified_Cybersecurity_Protection
- Wizer Cybersecurity Training – Free Security Awareness Training, Phishing Simulation and Gamification (wizer-training.com)
-/ 30 /-
Leave a Reply